By VICKI URBANIK
Less than a year old, the new bridge that accesses U.S. Steel’s Midwest
plant in Portage has developed cracks that are raising serious concerns for
county officials responsible with the bridge maintenance.
North Porter County Commissioner John Evans said the county will close the
bridge if the cracks become a public safety hazard and that the county may
want to terminate its agreement with the state requiring the county to
maintain the bridge.
As directed by the commissioners Tuesday, county attorney Gwenn Rinkenber
will write a letter to the Indiana Department of Transportation stating that
the county’s position is that the cracks are a construction issue, not a
maintenance issue, and are the responsibility of the state’s.
The bridge officially opened in July of last year with a highly festive
ceremony that featured U.S. Rep. Pete Visclosky, then-Indiana governor Joe
Kernan, a host of other state and local officials, and union and steel
officials.
The new, $6.1 million bridge -- known as the South Shore Industrial Safety
Overpass that extends from Ind. 249 -- replaces the at-grade crossing over
two sets of railroad tracks, one of which was the site of a triple fatality
in 1998 between a truck transporting a steel coil and a South Shore
passenger train. After that collision, the federal government called for
either closing the crossing or making permanent improvements. The latter was
accomplished through what was termed as a remarkable cooperative effort
between federal, state and local officials.
But today, county officials are far from happy with the bridge.
“Quite frankly, I don’t want anything to do with the bridge,” County Highway
Engineer Dave Schelling told the commissioners Tuesday.
Schelling displayed a photo of concrete that has broken off on the deck of
the bridge. The broken-off part has in turn caused other cracks to develop.
“That just tells me the concrete is going to pop out eventually,” he said.
Schelling said that at this point he does not believe that public safety is
jeopardized by the cracks, but that the cracks do point to the need for
maintenance soon. He noted that the bridge, which serves as the only access
to the Midwest plant, is used daily by heavy steel-hauling trucks.
Last year, during the opening ceremony, the statistic was given that 2,250
vehicles crossed the previous railroad tracks daily, 250 of which were
trucks going to and from the steel mill.
In an agreement signed with the state before the bridge was finished, the
county commissioners assumed maintenance responsibility. As Schelling noted
Tuesday, this was highly unusual, since all bridges that cross state
highways and interstates are maintained by the state, not the county.
But Evans said the commissioners were told by the state that the bridge
would never get built if the county didn’t agree to maintain it.
“We signed that agreement under duress,” Evans said.
Schelling said he does not know how much the repairs to the bridge would
cost. One of the problems is that the underside of the bridge is covered by
steel forms, making it difficult to ascertain the extent of the damage, he
said.
Schelling said one option that the county has is to place truck weight
limits on the bridge. The commissioners also discussed the possibility of
terminating its agreement with INDOT and, as Evans suggested, closing the
bridge if the damage worsens.
Rinkenberger said the damage described by Schelling appears to be connected
with the actual construction of the bridge. The state contracted out for the
bridge construction, not the county, so the responsibility lies with the
state, she said.
Posted 4/6/2005