NEW YORK (AP) — The scope and senselessness of the Newtown,
Conn., school shooting challenged journalists' ability to do much more
than lend, or impose, their presence on the scene.
Pressed with
the awful urgency of the story, television, along with other media, fell
prey to reporting "facts" that were often in conflict or wrong.
How many
people were killed? Which Lanza brother was the shooter: Adam or Ryan? Was
their mother, who was among the slain, a teacher at the school?
Like the rest
of the news media, television outlets were faced with intense competitive
pressures and an audience ravenous for details in an age when the
best-available information was seldom as reliable as the networks'
high-tech delivery systems.
Here was the
normal gestation of an unfolding story. But with wall-to-wall cable
coverage and second-by-second Twitter postings, the process of updating
and correcting it was visible to every onlooker. And as facts were
gathered by authorities, then shared with reporters (often on background),
a seemingly higher-than-usual number of points failed to pan out:
— The number
of dead was initially reported as anywhere from the high teens to nearly
30. The final count was established Friday afternoon: 20 children and six
adults, as well as Lanza's mother and the shooter himself.
— For hours on
Friday, the shooter was identified as Ryan Lanza, with his age
alternatively reported as 24 or 20. The confusion seemed explainable when
a person who had spoken with Ryan Lanza said that 20-year-old Adam Lanza,
the shooter who had then killed himself, could have been carrying
identification belonging to his 24-year-old sibling.
This case of
mistaken identity was painfully reminiscent of the Atlanta Olympics
bombing case in 1996, when authorities fingered an innocent man, and the
news media ran with it, destroying his life. Such damage was averted in
Ryan Lanza's case largely by his public protestations on social media,
repeatedly declaring "It wasn't me."
— Initial
reports differed as to whether Lanza's mother, Nancy, was shot at the
school, where she was said to be a teacher, or at the home she shared with
Adam Lanza. By Friday afternoon, it was determined that she had been shot
at their home.
Then doubts
arose about whether Nancy Lanza had any link to Sandy Hook Elementary. At
least one parent said she was a substitute teacher, but by early Saturday,
an official said investigators had been unable to establish any connection
with the school.
That seemed to
make the massacre even more confusing. Early on, the attack was said to
have taken place in her own classroom and was interpreted by more than one
on-air analyst as possibly a way for Adam Lanza to strike back at children
with whom he felt rivalry for his mother's affection.
— Lanza's
weapons were listed as two pistols (a Glock and a Sig Sauer) as well as a
.223-caliber Bushmaster rifle, but whether that rifle was used in the
school or left in the trunk of Lanza's car remained unclear.
— There were
numerous versions of what Lanza was wearing, including camouflage attire
and black paramilitary garb.
With so many
unanswered questions, TV correspondents were left to set the scene and to
convey the impact in words that continually failed them.
However apt,
the phrase "parents' worst nightmare" became an instant cliche.
And the word
"unimaginable" was used countless times. But "imagine" was exactly what
the horrified audience was helpless not to do.
The screen was
mostly occupied by grim or tearful faces, sparing everybody besides law
enforcement officials the most chilling sight: the death scene in the
school, where — as viewers were reminded over and over — the bodies
remained while evidence was gathered. But who could keep from imagining
it?
Ironically,
perhaps the most powerful video came from 300 miles away, in Washington,
where President Barack Obama delivered brief remarks about the tragedy.
His somber face, the flat tone of his voice, the tears he daubed from his
eyes, and his long, tormented pauses said as much as his heartfelt words.
He seemed to speak for everyone who heard them.
The Associated
Press was also caught in the swirl of imprecise information. When key
elements of the story changed, the AP issued two advisories — one to
correct that Adam Lanza, not his brother, was the gunman, and another that
called into question the original report that Lanza's mother taught at the
school.
But TV had
hours to fill.
Children from
the school were interviewed. It was a questionable decision for which the
networks took heat from media critics and viewers alike. But the decision
lay more in the hands of the willing parents (who were present), and there
was value in hearing what these tiny witnesses had to say.
"We had to
lock our doors so the animal couldn't get in," said one little boy, his
words painting a haunting picture.
In the absence
of much hard information, speculation was a regular fallback.
Correspondents and other "experts" persisted in diagnosing the shooter, a
man none of them had ever met or even heard of until hours earlier.
CNN's "Piers
Morgan Tonight" scored an interview with a former classmate of Lanza's —
with an emphasis on "former."
"I really only
knew him closely when we were very, very young, in elementary school
together," she said.
Determined to
unlock Lanza's personality, Morgan asked the woman if she "could have ever
predicted that he would one day flip and do something as monstrous as
this?"
"I don't know
if I could have predicted it," she replied, struggling to give Morgan what
he wanted. "I mean, there was something 'off' about him."
The larger
implications of the tragedy were broached throughout the coverage — not
least by Obama.
"We're going
to have to come together and take meaningful action to prevent more
tragedies like this, regardless of the politics," he said, which may have
gladdened proponents of stricter gun laws.
But CBS
correspondent Nancy Cordes noted, "There's often an assumption that after
a horrific event like this, it will spark a fierce debate on the issue.
But in recent years, that hasn't been the case."
Appearing on
"The O'Reilly Factor" Friday night, Fox News correspondent Geraldo Rivera
voiced his own solution.
"I want an
armed cop at every school," he said.
___
EDITOR'S NOTE
— Frazier Moore is a national television columnist for The Associated
Press. He can be reached at fmoore(at)ap.org and at
http://www.twitter.com/tvfrazier .