INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — The Democrat-led House and GOP-controlled Senate have
approved separate property tax relief and restructuring plans that each
contain key pieces of Gov. Mitch Daniels’ proposal on the overhaul.
Now the real negotiating begins, as a conference committee of Democrats and
Republicans from each chamber try to hammer out a final plan before the
legislative session ends March 14. Lawmakers are under public pressure to
enact property tax relief after some homeowners struggled with skyrocketing
bills last year.
But schools and local governments have lobbied extensively against parts of
the plans — primarily caps on property tax bills that they say could lead to
large reductions in their budgets and force them to cut services such as
public safety.
Many details could change as lawmakers seek a compromise, but here is a look
at some of the highlights of both plans as they passed the House and Senate:
TAX RELIEF
If fully implemented in 2010, the House plan is projected to cut homeowners’
property tax bills by about 29 percent on average statewide from what they
were last year. The Senate plan is estimated to cut bills by about 27 percent
over last year.
LIMITS ON TAX BILLS
The House plan caps homeowners’ property tax bills at 1 percent of their
homes’ assessed values beginning in 2009, with limits of 2 percent for rental
property and 3 percent for businesses. The Senate version phases in those
caps by 2010, but new bonding debt for major local projects would not count
against the caps.
CONSTITUTIONAL CAPS IN SEPARATE LEGISLATION
The Senate passed a resolution that would begin the process of amending the
tax-bill caps into the state constitution. New debt for projects approved in
referendums would not count against the caps. The House has modified that so
caps on homeowners’ bills are based on household income instead of assessed
value. Existing debt — about 30 percent of the property tax levy — would not
count against the caps. The House is expected to pass that version of the
resolution on Thursday.
SALES TAX
Both plans increase the state sales tax from 6 percent to 7 percent to help
pay for property tax relief.
QUICK HELP
The House plan adds $700 million in projected revenue from the tax increase
this year to $250 million already allocated for additional homestead credits,
for a total of about $950 million in homeowner tax relief in 2008. The Senate
plan would add $600 million in tax increase revenue to the $250 million to
provide $850 million in relief this year.
LEVIES SHIFTED
The House plan has the state paying the remaining 15 percent of local school
operating costs, and K-12 transportation costs and child welfare expenses.
The Senate plan has the state take over remaining school operating costs and
child welfare expenses. The state would also assume $90 million per year that
local governments owe for pre-1977 pension plans for police and firefighters,
and about $130 million a year in school pension debt.
SPENDING CONTROLS
The House version limits total local spending growth in each county, but
allows levies to go past the limits if approved in a referendum. The Senate
plan limits the amount local governments could spend in property tax revenue,
but not other sources of money such as local income taxes.
GOVERNMENT PROJECTS
The Senate plan subjects major local government and school construction
projects to referendums. The House plan is similar, but exempts school
construction projects related to learning. Stadiums and other sports
facilities, however, would still have to go through the referendum process.
ASSESSMENT DUTIES
The House plan eliminates township assessors, transferring their duties to
oversight of one county official. The Senate plan would allow local
referendums so people could choose whether assessments are done at the
township or county level.
RENTERS HELP
The House plan doubles the income tax deduction for renters from $2,500 to
$5,000. The Senate plan increases that deduction to $3,000.
2/28/2008